In The Atlantic today, a summary of a new article in Science Advances this week about speech evolution:
https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2019/12/when-did-ancient-humans-start-speak/603484/?utm_source=feed
https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/5/12/eaaw3916
I think Greg Hickok had the most trenchant comment, that people are hoping “that there was one thing that had to happen and that released the linguistic abilities.” And John Locke had the best bumper sticker, “Motor control rots when you die.”
As the authors say in the article, recent work has shown that primate vocal tracts are capable of producing some vowel sounds:
https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/2/12/e1600723
https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0169321
This is certainly interesting from a comparative physiological perspective, and the article has a great summary of tube models for vowels. But I don't think that "producing vowel sounds" should be equated with "having speech" in the sense of "having a phonological system". My own feeling is that we should be looking for a couple of things. First, the ability to pair non-trivial sound sequences (phonological representations) with meanings in long term memory. Some nonhuman animals (including dogs) do have this ability, or something like it, so this isn't the lynch pin.
http://science.sciencemag.org/content/304/5677/1682.short
Second, the emergence of speech sound sequencing abilities in both the motor and perceptual systems. That is, the ability to perform computations over sequences; to compose, decompose and manipulate sequences of speech sounds, which includes concatenation, reduplication, phonotactic patterning, phonological processes and so on. The findings closest to showing this for nonhuman animals (birds in this case) that I am aware of are in:
https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms10986
https://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/journal.pbio.2006532
In those papers the debate is framed in terms of syntax, which I think is misguided. But the experiments do show some sound sequencing abilities in the birds which might coincide with some aspects of human phonological abilities. But, of course, this would be an example of convergent evolution, so it tells us almost nothing about the evolutionary history in primates.
Regarding this: "[We should be looking for] the ability to pair non-trivial sound sequences (phonological representations) with meanings in long term memory."
ReplyDeleteIf this is so then it just means there's another discontinuity waiting around the corner.
ReplyDeletehello im a blogger too...i found out your blog on google,its a nice blog, full of information and i like to read your article, keep work.. would you mind to visit my blog too and give some suggestion to improve my blog.. this is my blog address :
Judi Online
We are one of the authorized people for bus branding in Chennai metropolitan across Tamilnadu. Bus Back Panel Advertising in Chennai, MTC - Chennai City Bus Advertisement, Bus Advertising Agency, Bus Ad Agency, Bus branding in Tamil Nadu, Bus back advertising size, Bus back advertising Chennai, Bus back advertising cost in Chennai, Government bus advertising, Bus advertising rates in Chennai
ReplyDeleteBus Advertising in Chennai
I think this is one of the most significant information for me.
ReplyDeleteAnd i’m glad reading your article. But want to remark on some general things, The site style
is ideal, the articles is really nice : D. Good job, cheers
Judi Togel
Agen Togel Terpercaya
Bandar Togel Terpercaya
Bandar Togel Terpercaya
Bandar Togel Singapura
Agen Sabung Ayam SV388
Agen Slot Online Deposit Pulsa
Agen Slot Online Terpercaya
If you're trying to burn fat then you have to get on this totally brand new custom keto diet.
ReplyDeleteTo create this service, licenced nutritionists, fitness couches, and cooks have joined together to develop keto meal plans that are productive, painless, economically-efficient, and delicious.
Since their launch in early 2019, 100's of people have already remodeled their body and well-being with the benefits a certified keto diet can give.
Speaking of benefits: clicking this link, you'll discover 8 scientifically-certified ones given by the keto diet.
Great info. Thanks. Other useful post here: Malvani Language
ReplyDeleteThis is sensible information! Where else will if ind out more?? Who runs this joint too? sustain the excellent function
ReplyDeleteDominoQQ
Judi Bola
Slot Online
Ceme Online
BCA368
BCA368
Hallo Para Bentor Judi Online Casino dan Sabung Ayam di indonesia..!!
ReplyDeleteKami SahabatCasino Agen Live Casino Online, AFB88 Sportbook, Slot dan Sabung Ayam Terpercaya hadir untuk memberikan peluang yang sangat besar untuk anda menjadi seorang jutawan !
Hanya dengan bermodal Rp 25.000,- anda bisa merasakan sensasi bermain sportbook, casino online dan sabung ayam.
Nikmati juga Berbagai Bonus Menarik dari SahabatCasino seperti :
= Bonus New Member 10% ( Minimal Deposit Rp. 100.000,- )
= Bonus Cashback Sportbook 5%
= Bonus Rollingan 0.8% ( otomatis terhitung setiap kali Anda memasang taruhan )
= Bonus Referal 3% ( Seumur Hidup )
= Bonus Extra Rollingan 0.3% ( Dibagikan Setiap Senin )
☎ Untuk informasi lebih lanjut, silahkan hubungi kami ☎
WA : +855964842196
Line : sahabatcasino
TELEGRAM : @sahabatcasino
Yahoo : cs1.sahabatcasino
Live Chat : sahabatcasino88.com {For PC}
Live Chat : sahabatcasino88.xyz {For Android}
AYOO JOIN SEKARANG JUGA
Hallo Para Bentor Judi Online Casino dan Sabung Ayam di indonesia..!!
ReplyDeleteKami SahabatCasino Agen Live Casino Online, AFB88 Sportbook, Slot dan Sabung Ayam Terpercaya hadir untuk memberikan peluang yang sangat besar untuk anda menjadi seorang jutawan !
Hanya dengan bermodal Rp 25.000,- anda bisa merasakan sensasi bermain sportbook, casino online dan sabung ayam.
Nikmati juga Berbagai Bonus Menarik dari SahabatCasino seperti :
= Bonus New Member 10% ( Minimal Deposit Rp. 100.000,- )
= Bonus Cashback Sportbook 5%
= Bonus Rollingan 0.8% ( otomatis terhitung setiap kali Anda memasang taruhan )
= Bonus Referal 3% ( Seumur Hidup )
= Bonus Extra Rollingan 0.3% ( Dibagikan Setiap Senin )
☎ Untuk informasi lebih lanjut, silahkan hubungi kami ☎
WA : +855964842196
Line : sahabatcasino
TELEGRAM : @sahabatcasino
Yahoo : cs1.sahabatcasino
Live Chat : sahabatcasino88.com {For PC}
Live Chat : sahabatcasino88.xyz {For Android}
AYOO JOIN SEKARANG JUGA
Want to win Sweepstakes? we have a large List of Online Sweepstakes, Online Contest, and Online Giveaways. Click on the website & enjoy all the offers. Hurry!
ReplyDeleteChristmas In July Sweepstakes| Sweepstakes-Online
free online Cash Sweepstakes| Sweepstakes-Online
QVC Christmas in July 25K Sweepstakes| Sweepstakes-Online
QVC Christmas In July Sweepstakes| Sweepstakes-Online
QVC Christmas In July Sweepstakes 2020| Sweepstakes-Online
SahabatQQ: Agen DominoQQ Agen Domino99 dan Poker Online Aman dan Terpercaya
ReplyDeleteWebsite SahabatQQ
WA 1 : +855887159498
WA 2 : +855972076840
Telegram 1 :+85515769793
Telegram 2 : +855972076840
LINE : SAHABATQQWIN
FACEBOOK : SahabatQQ Reborn
Agen Domino99